43 Custom Estate Homes • 4,000+ Sq. Ft. • Estate Homesites • Golf, Lake & Preserve Views

Tuscany Isle Homes for Sale at The Colony in Bonita Springs

Tuscany Isle is one of The Colony's premier custom-estate neighborhoods, combining individualized architecture, substantial homesites and some of the community's largest single-family residences.

Tuscany Isle
Homes For Sale

Tuscany Isle
Map Search

The Colony
Market Report

Custom Estate Living

Tuscany Isle contains approximately 43 custom residences rather than a limited collection of production floor plans. Homes begin around 4,000 square feet, many exceed 5,000 square feet and selected estates exceed 7,000 square feet.

Custom EstatesApproximately 43 individually designed residences.

Living Area4,000+ square feet, with substantially larger homes represented.

HomesitesLarge lots, frequently around one-half acre or more.

ViewsGolf course, lake, preserve and combinations of those settings.

Outdoor LivingLarge pools, spas, kitchens and extensive covered lanais.

GaragesThree- and four-car arrangements are common among larger estates.

Estate Homesites Matter

Lot size is only the beginning of the Tuscany Isle homesite analysis. Rear exposure, lake frontage, golf-course relationship, privacy, usable yard area, landscaping, driveway configuration and neighboring residences can materially influence value.

Tuscany Isle valuation sequence: homesite → living area → architecture and builder → construction year → lake/golf/preserve exposure → pool and outdoor living → garage → roof and storm protection → mechanical systems → renovation → strongest custom-estate comparables.

Extended Construction Era

Tuscany Isle developed over many years, with public records placing principal construction broadly from the late 1990s into the 2010s. Two neighboring estates can therefore differ materially in building-code generation, architectural style, roof age and mechanical systems.

Private Resort-Style Outdoor Living

Tuscany Isle estates commonly include large pools and spas, outdoor kitchens, fireplaces, cabanas, multiple covered living areas and mature landscaping. Larger lots can also support substantial guest accommodations and motor-court configurations.

Roof, Storm Protection and Insurance

RoofVerify installation date, material, permit and warranty.

Impact ProtectionConfirm windows, doors, sliders and garage openings.

GeneratorReview capacity, fuel source and service history.

HVACLarge estates may contain multiple systems and zones.

Pool SystemsInspect finish, automation, heaters, pumps and drainage.

InsuranceObtain property-specific homeowner, wind and flood analysis.

2026 Tuscany Isle Market

Tuscany Isle's current luxury inventory demonstrates the neighborhood's substantial range. Available estates include homes around 4,900 to more than 5,500 square feet, with asking prices currently extending from roughly the low-$3 million range through nearly $6 million.

Thin turnover makes neighborhood-wide averages particularly unreliable. Buyers and sellers should begin with the subject property's own history and the most similar Tuscany Isle estates before expanding to Bellagio, Messina or other Colony custom homes.

The Colony Lifestyle

Tuscany Isle homeowners participate in The Colony residential amenity structure, including the Bay Club on Estero Bay and applicable Pelican Landing private-beach, tennis, pickleball, fitness and water-recreation privileges.

Private membership at The Colony Golf & Country Club remains separate from ownership despite many Tuscany Isle homes physically overlooking the course.

Compare Colony Estate Neighborhoods

Bellagio

Messina

Ponza

Selling a Tuscany Isle Estate

Tuscany Isle marketing should document living area, acreage, builder, architectural design, lake/golf/preserve exposure, garage capacity, pool environment, roof history, hurricane protection, generator, major systems and significant renovations. Architectural plans, permit records and improvement histories are especially useful in this custom-estate market.

Explore Tuscany Isle With Schulz Realty

Schulz Realty can help evaluate Tuscany Isle as an individual custom-estate market rather than relying on broad Colony averages.

Contact Schulz Realty for Listings & Private Tours

Tuscany Isle Homes in Pelican Landing

$5,950,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4.5 Baths ⋅ 226012793 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 35,371 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 0.812 Acres

This is a unique opportunity to obtain an immediate Colony golf membership! Among the rarest offerings to emerge in Tuscany Isle within The Colony, this landmark single-family estate commands over 5,300 square feet of living space set upon more than three-quarters of an acre of immaculately curated landscaping. It offers a scale of privacy, proportion, and presence that defines true estate living in Southwest Florida's most prestigious golf community. This is not a home you simply live in; this is a home you retreat to. The outdoor living experience elevates this property to an entirely different category. Guest suites with their own private ensuite bathrooms, flank an expansive resort-style pool and entertaining terrace that captures the Florida sun at its most generous. The layout was conceived specifically for true outdoor entertaining at scale. An outdoor fire pit, a cozy fireplace with multiple covered living and dining areas, and lush professional landscaping complete a compound that functions as a private resort: beautiful, autonomous, and fully self-contained. Inside, Old Florida warmth and unparalleled craftsmanship meet without pretension. Exquisite millwork ceilings frame every room, highlighting warm and inviting interiors and a sensibility that is refined and genuinely livable, never ostentatious, always exceptional. The great room flows openly and generously, drawing family and guests naturally together while maintaining the unhurried ease that defines this home. A wine bar anchors the entertaining space, while professional Wolf appliances define an expansive, yet welcoming kitchen designed for both casual mornings and effortless holiday gatherings. The primary suite is exactly that: an oasis. Conceived as a private sanctuary within the estate, it offers the serenity and spa-caliber finish befitting a true retreat, with every detail considered and nothing overlooked. This is a true family compound, the rare property where three generations can gather under one roof, where guests arrive for a long weekend and stay for the week, and where every family unit feels equally at home. A spacious 3-car garage and a whole-house generator ensure seamless, uninterrupted enjoyment whether you are in residence or away. These details speak to the broader character of this home: nothing left to chance, nothing left to want. For the luxury buyer seeking an estate of genuine distinction, where guests experience the privacy of their own retreat while remaining warmly connected to the whole. Some estates are admired. This one is felt.

24000 Tuscany CT, Bonita Springs

$3,750,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4.5 Baths ⋅ 226001282 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24,568 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 0.5640000000000001 Acres

Welcome to 23821 Tuscany Court—a true estate residence tucked inside the prestigious community of The Colony Golf and Country Club in Pelican Landing, where architecture, craftsmanship, and lifestyle converge at the highest level. This custom built Estate home by McGarvey Custom Builders is a 4911-square-foot masterpiece, the definition of quiet luxury—designed for those who appreciate scale, elegance, and thoughtful detail at every turn. From the moment you arrive, the home commands attention with its stately presence, serene water features, and timeless architectural lines. Inside, soaring ceilings with intricate detailing draw your eye upward, while a double-sided fireplace anchors the living spaces with warmth and drama. Every room flows effortlessly, yet each feels intentional—crafted for both grand entertaining and refined everyday living. The chef’s gas kitchen, outfitted with cabinet-front appliances and custom finishes, opens seamlessly to the heart of the home, making it equally suited for entertaining, whether it be intimate dinners or unforgettable family gatherings. This residence offers 4 spacious bedrooms, 4.5 baths, a private den with custom built-ins, a formal dining room that opens to a courtyard garden, and a wet bar, all wrapped in rich millwork, marble flooring, and designer finishes throughout. Triple sliders take you from the indoor to the outdoor living and fill the home with natural light and tranquility. Step outside and experience a private resort of your own: a grand pool and spa, expansive paved lanai, outdoor kitchen with a seated bar, and living room space with a gas fireplace, built-in grill, and a separate cabana—all set against a backdrop of lush landscaping and peaceful water views. Whether hosting under the stars or enjoying a quiet morning by the pool, this space was built to impress and entertain all your family and friends. Located within Tuscany Isle, one of The Colony’s most exclusive enclaves, this estate delivers access to world-class amenities, a private 34-acre beach park with private boat shuttle transportation to and from the island, waterfront dining at The Bay Club, private kayak park, pickleball, bocce ball, tennis, championship 18-hole golf, and an unmatched Southwest Florida lifestyle. A legacy property. One of the rare opportunities to own one of The Colony’s finest estates. Don’t miss this opportunity to live in paradise. The best location, with dining and shopping at Coconut Point Mall just across the street, minutes to Naples, Waterside shops, and minutes to Southwest Regional International Airport!

23821 Tuscany CT, Estero

$3,299,000

4 Beds ⋅ 5.5 Baths ⋅ 226027884 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 25,570 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 0.587 Acres

Set on over half an acre with sweeping lake views, this extraordinary estate is located within Tuscany Isle, an intimate enclave of just 39 custom residences in The Colony at Pelican Landing. Offering 5,563 sq. ft. under air, 4 bedrooms plus den, 5 full and 1 half baths, private elevator and 3-car air-conditioned garage, this exceptional residence blends grand-scale architecture with relaxed Florida living. Beyond the double-door entry, a dramatic 21' two-story foyer introduces a magnificent living room with soaring 23' ceilings, marble floors, gas fireplace and walls of glass framing the lake and tranquil water feature. Beautiful wood tray and coffered ceilings, volume ceilings and architectural detailing add warmth and character throughout. The formal dining room leads to a custom chef's kitchen featuring Sub-Zero refrigeration, Thermador gas cooking, Miele dishwasher, double ovens, wine refrigeration, separate ice maker, custom cabinetry, built-in pantry and butler's pantry. The adjoining family room and breakfast area open through zero-edge sliders to spectacular outdoor living. The expansive first-floor primary retreat features a sitting area with morning kitchen, illuminated tray ceiling with cove lighting, two custom-fitted closets and a spacious bath with oversized shower and exceptional built-in storage. Upstairs, wood plank flooring flows through the bedrooms and loft. A private poolside cabana with full bath provides wonderful accommodations for guests. Outside, enjoy an infinity-edge, gas-heated saltwater pool and spa, expansive covered lanai, built-in outdoor kitchen and beautiful lake views. Notable enhancements include a newer flat-profile tile roof (2022), remarcited pool (2022), newer pool heater and pumps and upstairs A/C (2025), electric storm shutters and electric privacy shades throughout. Tuscany Isle residents enjoy The Colony lifestyle with waterfront dining at The Bay Club, private kayak park and access to Pelican Landing amenities, including a private 34-acre beach park with boat shuttle, tennis, pickleball, bocce and more. Championship golf membership opportunities are available. Ideally located near Coconut Point, Hyatt Regency Coconut Point Resort & Spa, Gulf beaches, Naples and RSW.

23810 Tuscany WAY, Bonita Springs

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.