Knights Bridge Homes at Kensington Naples Florida

Knights Bridge is a distinctive single-family home neighborhood in Naples, Florida, centered primarily along Old Gallows Way and Finchley Lane. The community is known for spacious custom residences, larger homesites, private pools and spas, substantial garages, and some exceptional combinations of lake and golf-course views.

Current MLS records identify Knights Bridge as its own subdivision and report approximately 85 residences within the community or association. Verified properties range from approximately 2,900 square feet to more than 5,700 square feet of air-conditioned living area, giving Knights Bridge considerable variety within a relatively private residential setting.

Knights Bridge Homes at a Glance

Old Gallows Way Homes

Old Gallows Way is the street most strongly associated with Knights Bridge in Southwest Florida MLS. It provides a quiet residential setting with large detached homes positioned around lakes and golf-course scenery.

Verified Old Gallows Way properties range from approximately 2,933 square feet to more than 5,700 square feet, illustrating how dramatically homes can differ within the same neighborhood.

The street includes both one-story and two-story architecture, private pool homes, courtyard residences, three-car garages and several premium lake-and-golf homesites.

Finchley Lane Homes

Finchley Lane is also represented within the Knights Bridge MLS subdivision. Documented residences include homes of approximately 3,291 and 3,485 square feet on lots around 0.36 to 0.40 acre.

Finchley Lane provides convenient access into the neighborhood while retaining the same detached custom-home character found along Old Gallows Way.

Golf, lake and landscaped views are represented among these properties.

Knights Bridge Home Sizes

Knights Bridge should not be treated as a neighborhood with one standard floor plan. Verified homes include approximately 2,933, 3,042, 3,090, 3,105, 3,291, 3,485, 3,964 and 5,718 square feet of living area.

This broad range makes individual property comparison especially important. A roughly 3,000-square-foot home and a 5,700-square-foot double-lot residence may share a Knights Bridge address but compete in very different segments of the Naples luxury market.

Three-Bedroom Plus Study Homes

Three-bedroom-plus-study floor plans are well represented in Knights Bridge. A documented 5232 Old Gallows Way residence provides approximately 2,933 square feet with three bedrooms, a study and three full bathrooms.

This layout offers dedicated guest accommodations while preserving a private office or library.

For buyers who do not need four formal bedrooms, a substantial three-bedroom-plus-study design can provide an excellent balance of space and functionality.

Four-Bedroom Plus Den Homes

Four-bedroom-plus-den configurations appear among Knights Bridge's larger residences. A documented 5208 Old Gallows Way property provides approximately 3,964 square feet with four bedrooms plus a separate den and four full bathrooms.

Current 2026 inventory also includes a much larger four-bedroom home exceeding 5,700 square feet, demonstrating the estate-scale living available within the neighborhood.

Single-Story Estate Homes

Large single-story residences are a major Knights Bridge feature. Verified homes of approximately 3,042, 3,291, 3,485, 3,964 and 5,718 square feet are all represented in one-level designs.

Keeping the bedrooms, kitchen, living areas, laundry, garage and pool on one floor can make even a substantial estate easier to use for long-term ownership.

Single-story design also creates strong indoor-outdoor connections because living spaces can open directly toward the lanai, pool, lake and golf course.

Two-Story Knights Bridge Homes

Two-story architecture is also represented. A documented 5180 Old Gallows Way property provides approximately 3,105 square feet with four bedrooms, five bathrooms and an upper-level suite overlooking the golf and lake setting.

Second-floor guest suites can provide valuable separation when family or visitors stay for extended periods.

Custom Home Architecture

Knights Bridge includes individually designed homes rather than one repeating production model. Architecture varies in room configuration, ceiling height, courtyards, guest suites, garage arrangements and outdoor living.

Custom millwork, tray ceilings, volume ceilings, fireplaces, wet bars, substantial kitchens and formal entertaining rooms are represented throughout neighborhood listings.

This variety makes the actual home more important than simply knowing the subdivision name.

Arthur Rutenberg Homes

Arthur Rutenberg-designed residences are represented within Knights Bridge. A documented 5208 Old Gallows Way home is a custom Arthur Rutenberg design with four bedrooms plus den, renovated kitchen, private pool and spa, and a three-car garage.

Builder pedigree can provide useful context, but renovations completed over the past two decades may significantly alter the original floor plan and finishes.

Bayside Floor Plan

The Bayside design is represented at 5232 Old Gallows Way. The documented home offers approximately 2,933 square feet with three bedrooms plus study, three bathrooms and extensive outdoor living.

The residence takes advantage of wraparound lake views and scenery toward the 9th-hole green.

Courtyard Estate Homes

Courtyard architecture is another distinctive Knights Bridge feature. A documented 5220 Old Gallows Way home uses a private courtyard pool and spa surrounded by interior living areas and a separate guest casita.

This design provides a highly private outdoor environment while maintaining a second visual connection toward golf and lake scenery.

Private Guest Casitas

Guest casitas are represented in select courtyard residences. A detached or semi-private guest suite can be especially valuable for visiting family, long-term guests or buyers who need a private office separated from the main residence.

The casita configuration is not standard throughout Knights Bridge and should be treated as a premium property-specific feature.

Private Pools and Spas

Private swimming pools are common throughout Knights Bridge. Pool environments range from courtyard designs to large rear lanais overlooking lakes and golf-course fairways.

Integrated spas, electric heat, solar heat and saltwater systems are all represented in verified properties.

Buyers should review pool surface, pumps, heating systems, automation, spa equipment and screen enclosures when comparing homes.

Large Covered Lanais

Knights Bridge homes frequently provide substantial covered outdoor living. Large lanais may contain separate dining, lounging and entertaining areas.

The size and orientation of the covered area can be especially important on western-exposure homes, where afternoon sun may otherwise be intense.

Outdoor Kitchens

Built-in outdoor kitchens are represented in several Knights Bridge homes. A documented 5232 Old Gallows Way residence includes a grill and outdoor kitchen positioned beneath substantial covered lanai space.

Outdoor kitchens can be particularly valuable when paired with a premium lake-and-golf view because the lanai becomes a primary entertaining area.

Lakefront Knights Bridge Homes

Lake frontage is one of Knights Bridge's strongest real estate characteristics. Water provides additional separation behind the residence and creates an attractive backdrop from the kitchen, living areas, primary suite and pool.

Verified lakefront properties are found along both Old Gallows Way and Finchley Lane.

Lake width and the scenery beyond the water should be evaluated carefully because these characteristics can influence resale value.

Golf Course Views

Golf-course views are widely represented throughout Knights Bridge. Documented properties overlook different portions of the course, including the 1st, 2nd and 9th-hole areas.

Open fairway scenery can substantially increase the visual scale of a homesite.

Buyers should consider cart paths, tees, greens, landing areas and natural buffers when comparing golf-facing properties.

1st-Hole Views

A documented Old Gallows Way courtyard estate overlooks the 1st-hole fairway along with lake scenery.

The residence uses large lanais and pocketing sliders to connect the interior and outdoor spaces directly with the view.

2nd-Hole Views

5180 Old Gallows Way is documented with expansive views toward the 2nd hole, lakes and surrounding golf scenery.

The two-story residence uses both ground-level outdoor living and an upper balcony to take advantage of the setting.

9th-Hole Views

5232 Old Gallows Way is positioned with wraparound lake views toward the 9th-hole green.

The lake creates separation between the home and active golf play while retaining a strong golf-course panorama.

Lake and Golf Views

The combination of water and golf scenery is arguably Knights Bridge's most important homesite feature. Many documented residences are oriented so water sits between the home and fairway.

This layered view provides visual depth and can reduce direct exposure to golf activity compared with a home positioned immediately along the fairway.

Western Rear Exposure

Western rear exposure is represented among premium Knights Bridge homes. Current 2026 inventory includes a west-facing Old Gallows Way property with pool, lake and golf views.

Western orientation can provide dramatic evening sunsets but should be evaluated together with covered lanai depth and afternoon heat.

Lots Around 0.35 to 0.40 Acre

Many verified Knights Bridge homesites are approximately 0.35 to 0.40 acre. Examples include 0.35-, 0.36- and 0.40-acre parcels on Old Gallows Way and Finchley Lane.

These lots provide room for custom homes, private pools, large garages and landscaping while remaining more manageable than acre-plus estate properties.

Oversized and Double Lots

Knights Bridge also includes exceptional oversized properties. Current 2026 inventory at 5215 Old Gallows Way occupies approximately 0.73 acre created from a rare double-lot configuration.

The homesite measures substantially larger than typical Knights Bridge parcels and accommodates a 5,718-square-foot residence, large pool environment and three-car side-entry garage.

Two-Car and Golf-Cart Garages

Some Knights Bridge residences use two conventional vehicle bays plus additional golf-cart or sports-car storage.

A documented 5232 Old Gallows Way home includes an oversized garage with two primary vehicle spaces plus an additional garage door for a golf cart or smaller vehicle.

This configuration can provide greater utility than a conventional two-car garage.

Three-Car Garages

Three-car garages are strongly represented among Knights Bridge homes. Verified properties on Old Gallows Way and Finchley Lane include attached three-car configurations.

Some garages are side-entry designs, helping preserve the home's front architectural appearance.

Air-conditioned garage space is also represented in upgraded properties.

Construction Era

Verified Knights Bridge properties were built primarily from the mid-1990s through approximately 2001. Documented examples include homes built in 1995, 1998, 1999, 2000 and 2001.

This established construction period makes renovation history particularly important.

Two homes built within a year of each other may now differ substantially in roof, windows, mechanical systems, plumbing, pool equipment and interior condition.

Renovated Knights Bridge Homes

Significant renovations are represented throughout the neighborhood. Updated properties may include redesigned kitchens, premium appliances, wood or luxury flooring, renovated bathrooms, fireplaces, custom bars and new hurricane windows.

A documented 5208 Old Gallows Way residence received extensive interior upgrades, including a gourmet kitchen, four renovated bathrooms, hurricane windows and upgraded outdoor living.

Kitchen Renovations

Larger Knights Bridge homes can include expansive kitchens with oversized islands, walk-in pantries, butler's pantries and multiple appliances.

Current 2026 inventory includes a residence with a large island, breakfast bar, morning area, walk-in pantry and separate butler's pantry.

Because kitchen scale varies substantially, buyers should evaluate cabinetry, appliance quality, work surfaces and storage independently from overall living area.

Hurricane Protection

Storm protection varies by individual property. Verified homes include electric shutters and newer hurricane-resistant windows.

Large sliding openings around pools and lanais deserve particular attention because protecting them can require specialized systems.

Buyers should verify protection for every exterior opening.

Whole-House Generators

Generators are represented among upgraded Knights Bridge residences. Current and historical MLS homes include generator systems designed to support larger properties during outages.

Generator capacity, fuel source, service history and installation permits should be reviewed during due diligence.

Solar Equipment

Solar equipment is represented in current Knights Bridge inventory, including solar-assisted pool heating and solar power features.

Buyers should verify ownership versus lease arrangements, equipment age, warranties and any impact on roof maintenance.

Knights Bridge Association Structure

Current MLS listings show mandatory association obligations for Knights Bridge properties, along with broader community-related fees. However, fee structures and the way individual MLS systems label neighborhood, master and club-related charges are not always consistent.

For that reason, buyers should verify the current association structure using the property's actual estoppel rather than relying on an older listing or a portal's simplified fee field.

What Association Fees May Cover

Recent Knights Bridge MLS records identify services that may include combinations of lawn and landscape maintenance, irrigation water, cable or internet access, professional management, reserves, security, street lighting and street maintenance.

The exact services vary by listing and may reflect different association layers.

Current documents should control over historical marketing information.

Architectural Restrictions

Knights Bridge properties are subject to architectural and deed restrictions. Exterior changes involving roofing, windows, doors, paint, landscaping, driveways, pools, generators and other visible improvements may require approval.

Buyers planning a major renovation should review current architectural requirements before closing.

Pet and Vehicle Rules

Current and historical MLS records identify pet limitations and restrictions affecting commercial vehicles, recreational vehicles and certain trucks.

Rules may change, so buyers with specific pets or vehicles should verify the current written restrictions.

Rental Considerations

Historical Knights Bridge MLS records show leasing restrictions, including limits on frequency and minimum lease periods.

Buyers intending to rent a home should review the current governing documents before relying on older MLS information.

Recent Knights Bridge Sales

Recent Knights Bridge transactions provide useful neighborhood-specific comparable evidence. A 3,090-square-foot home at 5181 Old Gallows Way sold for $2.65 million, while a 2,933-square-foot residence at 5232 Old Gallows Way sold for $1.84 million in May 2025.

The difference between those sales demonstrates why interior renovation, homesite, view, garage arrangement and overall condition must be considered alongside square footage.

Current Knights Bridge Inventory

Current 2026 inventory includes an unusually large 5215 Old Gallows Way estate with approximately 5,718 square feet, four bedrooms, four bathrooms, a three-car garage and a 0.73-acre double lot.

The property combines private pool and spa living with lake and golf views, illustrating the upper end of Knights Bridge's residential scale.

Knights Bridge Comparable Sales

Knights Bridge comparable sales should be selected carefully because the neighborhood contains meaningful differences in living area and homesite size.

A 2,933-square-foot residence on a conventional lot should not automatically be compared directly with a 5,718-square-foot home occupying two lots.

Comparable analysis should account for living area, homesite acreage, story count, garage capacity, pool design, lake frontage, golf position and renovation quality.

Price Per Square Foot

Price per square foot is useful only as one component of Knights Bridge valuation.

Premium lake-and-golf views, oversized lots, courtyard architecture, guest casitas, three-car garages, newer mechanical systems and extensive renovations can all create significant differences between homes.

The individual residence and land should remain the primary basis for comparison.

What Knights Bridge Buyers Should Compare

Why Buyers Choose Knights Bridge

Knights Bridge offers an attractive middle ground between smaller single-family golf homes and much larger Naples estate communities. Many residences provide roughly 3,000 to 4,000 square feet, substantial lots, private pools and three-car garages.

At the same time, exceptional properties can extend beyond 5,500 square feet and occupy oversized or double homesites.

The neighborhood's strongest homes combine generous indoor space with lake and golf views that can be enjoyed from the primary living rooms and outdoor areas.

Knights Bridge for Full-Time Living

Large single-story floor plans, three- and four-bedroom configurations, home offices and substantial garages make Knights Bridge well suited to full-time Naples residents.

Homes can provide enough space for extended family, guests and work-from-home needs without requiring multi-acre estate maintenance.

Knights Bridge for Seasonal Owners

Seasonal buyers may also appreciate Knights Bridge, particularly homes with association-supported landscaping and irrigation services.

Owners should still plan for private pool service, storm preparation, mechanical-system monitoring and home-watch services while away.

Knights Bridge Versus Kensington Park

County legal descriptions can create confusion because Old Gallows Way parcels may be legally platted within Kensington Park Phase One. Current MLS, however, separately identifies these properties as Knights Bridge.

For real estate search and comparable-sale purposes, homes marketed under the Knights Bridge MLS subdivision should remain associated with Knights Bridge rather than being absorbed into a generic Kensington Park page.

Knights Bridge as an MLS Community

Knights Bridge is tracked separately on this website because KNIGHTS BRIDGE appears as a specific Southwest Florida MLS subdivision designation.

Current Naples Area Board of Realtors data identifies recent Old Gallows Way transactions specifically as Kensington > Knights Bridge.

This community-level approach produces more relevant search results and more accurate neighborhood comparables than blending Knights Bridge with other Kensington single-family communities.

Knights Bridge Within Kensington

Knights Bridge is located within gated Kensington Golf & Country Club, but its real estate identity is defined by Old Gallows Way, Finchley Lane, custom single-family homes, larger lots, private pools, garages and premium lake-and-golf settings.

Private-club membership should be evaluated separately according to the specific property and current club offerings. Membership categories, availability, initiation requirements and dues can change.

Explore Knights Bridge With Schulz Realty

Schulz Realty helps buyers and sellers evaluate Knights Bridge homes in Naples, Florida. Comparing Old Gallows Way and Finchley Lane residences by living area, homesite size, lake and golf views, pool, garage configuration, construction, renovations, association obligations and recent Knights Bridge sales can provide a clearer picture of each property's individual value.