(239) 682-5800 Naples Luxury Homes & Condos | Schulz Realty Buyers Agents
Bay Colony Shores Homes

Custom Luxury Estates • Lake & Landscape Views • Private Pools • Guard-Gated Bay Colony

Bay Colony Shores Homes for Sale in Naples Florida

Bay Colony Shores is a private custom-estate neighborhood within the guard-gated Bay Colony section of Pelican Bay in Naples. Individually designed luxury homes, lake and landscaped settings, private pools, substantial outdoor living areas, attached garages and mature tropical surroundings create a distinctly residential alternative to Bay Colony's high-rise condominium towers.

Bay Colony Shores homes should be evaluated individually because architecture, construction quality, homesite size, lake exposure, floor plan, renovation history, pool design, garage capacity, roof age, mechanical systems and outdoor living can differ substantially from one estate to another.

Bay Colony Shores at a Glance

Property Type Custom luxury single-family estate homes.
Homesite Settings Lakefront, landscaped and private residential settings vary by property.
Outdoor Living Private pools, spas, lanais, outdoor kitchens and garden areas are common.
Buyer Focus Homesite, construction, renovation, roof, systems, pool, garage, insurance and association obligations.

A Private Estate-Home Neighborhood

Bay Colony Shores provides the privacy and individuality of a custom single-family residence while retaining the controlled-access environment and coastal lifestyle associated with Bay Colony and Pelican Bay.

Private driveways, attached garages, individual homesites and lower-density surroundings distinguish the neighborhood from nearby condominium towers.

Custom Architecture & Construction

Bay Colony Shores does not have one standardized home design. Residences have been created and renovated at different times by different architects, builders and designers, producing meaningful differences in architectural style, construction quality, ceiling heights, room arrangements and finish level.

Buyers should consider original construction quality together with subsequent additions and renovations. A beautifully updated interior should not automatically be treated as equivalent to a residence with newer structural components, impact-resistant openings, current mechanical systems and substantial permitted capital improvements.

Bay Colony Shores Floor Plans

Homes can include expansive great rooms, formal and casual dining areas, offices, libraries, media rooms, wine rooms, guest suites, elevators and flexible spaces designed for entertaining or multigenerational living.

Primary Suite

Compare location, privacy, outdoor access, closets, bathroom design and relationship to the permanent view.

Guest Suites

Evaluate bedroom separation, private baths, independent entrances and guest-living flexibility.

Kitchen & Entertaining

Consider workflow, storage, pantry space, appliance quality and connection to indoor and outdoor living areas.

Flexible Rooms

Offices, libraries, media rooms and fitness areas can materially affect usability for full-time or seasonal ownership.

Homesite Size, Position & Privacy

Homesite characteristics are among the most important permanent value factors in Bay Colony Shores. Compare lot width and depth, orientation, corner or cul-de-sac position, neighboring exposure, privacy and the relationship between the residence and surrounding water or landscaping.

A particularly well-positioned homesite can continue to influence value long after interior finishes have changed.

Lakefront Bay Colony Shores Homes

Many notable Bay Colony Shores residences take advantage of lake or water views. Buyers should evaluate the width and depth of the water exposure, orientation, landscaping, neighboring structures, privacy and how the view is experienced from the principal living areas, primary suite and outdoor spaces.

Lakefront value should be considered together with homesite orientation and usable outdoor living rather than treated as one identical premium throughout the neighborhood.

Private Pools, Spas & Outdoor Living

Outdoor living is a defining element of many Bay Colony Shores estates. Properties may include resort-style pools, spas, covered lanais, outdoor kitchens, cabanas, fireplaces, gardens and extensive screened or open-air entertaining spaces.

Pool & Spa

Review surface condition, equipment, heater, pumps, automation, lighting and renovation history.

Screen Enclosure

Inspect structural framing, screening, fasteners, doors and documented storm repairs where applicable.

Outdoor Kitchen

Check appliances, cabinetry, gas supply, ventilation and exposure to weather.

Rear Exposure

Compare sunlight, shade, afternoon heat, sunset potential and the relationship to lake or landscape views.

Garages, Elevators & Generators

Attached garages are an important part of Bay Colony Shores estate ownership. Some residences offer three-car, four-car or larger arrangements, while individual garages can also provide climate control, cabinetry and significant storage.

Select multistory homes have private elevators. Buyers should review elevator age, maintenance history, inspection status and emergency systems when applicable.

Whole-house generators are also present in selected properties. Generator capacity, fuel source, age, service records and the circuits served should be confirmed for the individual residence.

Renovation, Roofs & Major Systems

Bay Colony Shores spans multiple construction and renovation periods. Two homes with similar living area can therefore represent substantially different capital-condition profiles.

Roof

Verify roof age, permit history, materials, underlayment and documented repairs.

Storm Protection

Identify impact-resistant windows and doors, shutters and hurricane-rated garage doors.

HVAC & Mechanical

Review system age, zoning, maintenance records, humidity management and replacement history.

Plumbing & Electrical

Review major upgrades, panels, fixtures, water-heating systems and permitted improvements.

Insurance & Coastal Due Diligence

Insurance should be evaluated for the exact Bay Colony Shores property rather than estimated from another neighborhood residence. Replacement cost, roof, wind mitigation, impact protection, elevation, flood classification, claims history and the scale of the residence can materially influence coverage and premiums.

Buyers should obtain current property-specific insurance information during the due-diligence period.

Association & Ownership Review

Buyers should review current Bay Colony Shores, Bay Colony and applicable Pelican Bay documents rather than relying on historical listing remarks.

Assessments & Fees

Review current obligations and any approved or reasonably known future assessments.

Architectural Standards

Confirm procedures for exterior changes, roofing, additions, landscaping and redevelopment.

Rental & Pet Rules

Review current use, leasing, guest, vehicle and pet provisions.

Maintenance

Confirm owner and association responsibilities for private property and shared community elements.

Bay Colony Beach & Coastal Lifestyle

Bay Colony Shores residents live within the broader Bay Colony coastal environment. Depending on current ownership provisions and community requirements, privileges may include access to private Gulf-front facilities, attended beach service, dining, tennis and social opportunities.

Exact privileges, fees, guest rules and access requirements should be verified through current Bay Colony and Pelican Bay documents.

Private Golf Membership Is Separate

Private golf membership is separate from purchasing a Bay Colony Shores residence. Buyers whose decision depends on golf access should independently verify current membership categories, availability, initiation or capital requirements, annual dues, waiting conditions and privileges directly with the applicable private club.

How to Evaluate Bay Colony Shores Home Values

Valuation should begin with recent Bay Colony Shores transactions whenever genuinely comparable homes exist. Because the neighborhood contains individually designed estates, broad price-per-square-foot averages require careful interpretation.

A newer lakefront residence with a superior homesite, current roof, impact protection, significant outdoor living and a large garage can compete very differently from an older residence with similar reported living area but substantial modernization needs.

Bay Colony Shores valuation hierarchy: Bay Colony Shores → homesite → lake or privacy exposure → architecture and construction quality → floor plan → living area → outdoor living → garage → renovation and major systems → insurance considerations → association obligations → strongest relevant comparable sales.

Bay Colony vs. The Estates at Bay Colony Golf Club

The similar names can create confusion. On the current Agent4Naples MLS and site architecture, The Estates at Bay Colony Golf Club belongs under Pelican Marsh , not within the coastal Bay Colony residential directory.

For that reason, The Estates should not be used as a primary same-community comparison for Bay Colony Shores homes. Bay Colony Shores should be compared first with its own estate sales and, when appropriate, with other genuinely competitive coastal Bay Colony estate or villa properties.

Selling a Bay Colony Shores Home

Effective Bay Colony Shores marketing should emphasize permanent and difficult-to-reproduce characteristics such as homesite position, lake exposure, privacy, architectural design, construction quality, garage capacity and outdoor living.

Documentation for roof replacement, impact-resistant openings, HVAC systems, generator, elevator, pool improvements, plumbing, electrical work, smart-home systems, permitted renovations and transferable warranties can help buyers understand the depth of a property's capital improvements.

Explore Bay Colony Shores With Schulz Realty

Schulz Realty helps buyers and sellers compare Bay Colony Shores estates according to homesite position, lake or landscape exposure, architecture, construction quality, floor plan, renovation depth, roof age, storm protection, pool and outdoor living, garage capacity, major mechanical systems, insurance considerations and relevant Bay Colony Shores comparable sales.

Contact Schulz Realty for Listings & Private Tours

Bay Colony Shores, Bay Colony and Pelican Bay association fees, assessments, maintenance responsibilities, beach and racquet privileges, private-club memberships, insurance requirements, architectural standards, rental restrictions, pet policies, guest procedures and individual property characteristics may change or vary. Private golf membership is separate from residential ownership. Buyers should verify material information through current governing documents, Club information, insurance professionals, property inspections, title documentation and other appropriate qualified professionals before purchasing.

Current Bay Colony Shores Homes for Sale

Browse the native RealGeeks MLS listings below for current Bay Colony Shores inventory. Begin comparisons with homesite position, lake or landscape setting, living area, architecture, outdoor living, garage capacity, roof, storm protection, mechanical systems and renovation rather than relying only on broad Bay Colony averages.

Back to Top ↑

Bay Colony Shores Homes

7199 TORY LN, Naples
$13,000,000
5 Beds ⋅ 7.5 Baths ⋅ 224020552 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status ⋅ 20,909 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 0.48 Acres
Nestled on a prime corner lot within the secure confines of the gated beachfront community, Bay Colony, this extraordinary residence is a masterpiece of architectural finesse. Conceived by the renowned H-Level Architecture and meticulously crafted by Nian Custom Homes, the home seamlessly integrates contemporary sophistication with the quintessential resort-style living emblematic of Florida. As one of Bay Colony's most expansive residences, this two-story marvel effortlessly harmonizes indoor and outdoor spaces, creating an ambiance that is both refined and recreational—a true embodiment of opulent living. The interior of this distinguished property boasts five en-suite bedrooms, including an in-law suite with its private entrance, a secluded study, a two-story volume game room/bar, a state-of-the-art chef's kitchen adorned with custom Italian cabinetry and a butler's pantry, a transparent wine room, an elevator for added convenience, a media room, lake-view balconies, and a capacious three-car garage. Outside, the estate unfolds to reveal a resort-style saltwater pool and spa with a swim-up bar and sun deck, a gourmet summer kitchen, and an outdoor living area complete with a bespoke fireplace. Residents are treated to an array of premier amenities at Bay Colony, including access to the exclusive beach club, private beachfront dining, a tennis club, concierge services, and the option to join the esteemed Bay Colony Golf Club. This residence stands as an embodiment of unparalleled luxury, striking the perfect equilibrium between refined elegance and leisurely extravagance. Furnishings provided by Robb & Stucky Interiors & Furnishings.

7199 TORY LN, Naples

385 Colony DR, Naples
$12,995,000
6 Beds ⋅ 7.5 Baths ⋅ 226035651 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 30,492 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 0.7 Acres
An extraordinary combination of space, privacy, and collector-worthy garage capacity distinguishes this lakefront estate at 385 Colony Drive in Bay Colony Shores. Occupying one and a half lots at the end of a cul-de-sac, the residence encompasses nearly eight thousand square feet under air, with an expansive layout that brings exceptional versatility to luxury Naples living. For the automobile enthusiast, garage accommodations for up to twelve cars introduce a defining feature: the ability to house an extensive collection within your own private estate. Paired with the generous homesite and substantial living space, this offering deserves the attention of buyers seeking something distinctive. The main residence features four spacious bedrooms, two offices, and two gyms, providing dedicated settings for work, wellness, and relaxation. An attached guesthouse with two bedrooms and two baths extends the accommodations, allowing visitors to enjoy their own retreat while remaining connected to the home. At the heart of the residence, a kitchen with dual islands offers generous space for preparation and gathering, equally suited to intimate evenings and larger celebrations. A walk-in wine room adds another dimension to entertaining, keeping favorite vintages close at hand. Outdoors, the expansive covered lanai frames beautiful lake views and a striking waterfall-edge pool. Western exposure brings the evening sky into focus, creating an inviting backdrop for sunset gatherings, leisurely afternoons by the water, and dinner overlooking the lake. The setting encourages you to linger, with space to entertain beneath the covered lanai or simply enjoy the changing light across the water. From its generous grounds to its remarkable garage and separate guest accommodations, this estate offers the flexibility to make Naples living distinctly your own. Discover the possibilities of this exceptional Bay Colony Shores address, and arrange a private showing to experience the scale, setting, and lifestyle that distinguish this property.

385 Colony DR, Naples

333 Sedgwick CT, Naples
$11,995,000
6 Beds ⋅ 7.5 Baths ⋅ 225077753 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 17,424 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 0.4 Acres
Nestled behind the private gates of Bay Colony Shores, this masterful coastal-contemporary residence, originally crafted by BCB Homes and brilliantly expanded in 2016 by Covelli Construction with a seamless 1,600-sq-ft addition, is the epitome of refined luxury. Completely reimagined with countless recent enhancements, this 6-bedroom, 8-bath (6 full, 2 half) estate rivals the finest new construction in Naples’ most exclusive enclave. Step inside to soaring custom ceilings, walls of glass, and light-drenched living spaces that blend sophisticated design with effortless livability. The gourmet kitchen is a culinary masterpiece, appointed with Sub-Zero refrigeration, Wolf appliances, dual wine towers, a hidden butler’s pantry, and a temperature-controlled glass wine cellar. A dramatic great room flows to the cozy family room, while the palatial downstairs primary wing offers dual spa-inspired baths (remodeled 2023), expansive bespoke closets, and serene lake views. Upstairs, five generous en-suite bedrooms provide ultimate privacy for family and guests. A resort-caliber laundry suite features high-capacity appliances, abundant folding counters, custom cabinetry, a deep utility sink, built-in ironing station, and even a dedicated pet spa. Outdoors, the lakefront oasis beckons with a newly resurfaced and re-equipped pool/spa (new heater & pump 2025), expansive covered lanais, summer kitchen, and multiple conversation areas perfect for al fresco entertaining against a backdrop of shimmering water views. Additional 2022-2025 upgrades include a full roof replacement (2022), redesigned entry bath (2023), new AC systems, smart-home integration, and countless bespoke finishes throughout. Residents of Bay Colony Shores enjoy a private clubhouse with formal and casual dining, state-of-the-art fitness center, tennis, pickleball, and exclusive access to the legendary Bay Colony Beach Club — attended beach service, chic seaside dining, and sunset cocktails on the Gulf of Mexico. Optional world-class golf is available at either the Bay Colony Golf Club or neighboring Pelican Bay. Perfectly positioned just moments from Waterside Shops, Artis—Naples, 5th Avenue South, and Mercato, this impeccable estate offers the very best of Naples’ luxury lifestyle. An extraordinary opportunity to own a turnkey masterpiece in one of the area’s most coveted addresses.

333 Sedgwick CT, Naples

364 Colony DR, Naples
$11,995,000
6 Beds ⋅ 7.5 Baths ⋅ 225034564 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status ⋅ 44,431 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 1.02 Acres
A 2013 Masterpiece nestled on a private acre-plus lot with lake views, this elegant custom home designed by Stofft Cooney Architects, built by Vincent Borelli, and with interior design and decor by Collins and Dupont, is a superb example of refined, timeless luxury. The home has every detail your heart desires, with a beautifully connected floor plan perfect for all types of entertaining, while still intimate enough to enjoy as a family home. With many luxurious details, including intricate ceiling millwork, a temperature-controlled wine-room, walk-in wet-bar with beverage refrigerator, butler's pantry and an elevator. The home features a primary suite plus 4 guest suites plus an attached, but separate, guest retreat with a 6th bedroom and sitting room, which could be an exercise studio, mother-in-law suite or a variety of other possibilities. The exterior spaces are perfect, benefiting from the oversized lot with lake views with an outdoor kitchen and extensive lanais for relaxing and dining, all featuring motorized screens and shutters, and a gas fire-pit for relaxing on chillier evenings. The pool and spa area has a shady cabana with pool bathroom, outdoor shower and storage, and there is a Kohler whole home generator for peace of mind. Located in Flood Zone X.500 with a 12.5' elevation, the home was a safe refuge in recent storms and suffered no damage or flooding. Bay Colony is Naples' luxury living at its finest, with its private beach club renowned for elegant 5-star dining, a sparkling beach-side pool with poolside bar, extensive beach services, and is available to Bay Colony residents and guests only.

364 Colony DR, Naples

328 SEDGWICK CT, Naples
$7,200,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5.5 Baths ⋅ 226011896 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 16,988 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 0.39 Acres
Tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac in prestigious Bay Colony Shores, this extensively renovated estate sits on an over- sized .39-acre homesite with coveted south eastern exposure and offers an exceptional blend of modern luxury and timeless coastal elegance. This renovated the residence showcases impeccable craftsmanship including French oak flooring throughout the main living areas, marble bathroom floors, all new doors, baseboards, hardware, and full hurricane impact windows and doors. The heart of the home is the spectacular chef’s kitchen featuring dramatic Taj Mahal quartzite double islands, custom cabinetry, built-in banquette seating, a Miele built-in coffee system, water filtration system at kitchen sink, Thermador under-counter microwave, Thermador Refrigerator and separate Freezer. Miele dishwashers, and a Mercury induction cooktop. An impressive separate bar area is designed for entertaining with its own dishwasher, sink, wine cooler, ice maker beverage refrigerator, and abundant storage. Offering five spacious ensuite bedrooms plus an additional powder bath, every bathroom has been beautifully renovated with luxurious marble finishes. The fifth ensuite bedroom also functions as a convenient pool bath. The primary suite is a private retreat featuring a separate sitting area, a dramatic dual-sided fireplace shared with a private office/lounge with beverage refrigerator, and a spa-inspired bath complete with Taj Mahal countertops, a large walk-through shower with multiple shower heads and body sprays, dual bench seating, extensive custom cabinetry, soaking tub, and separate water closet with additional built in cabnitry. Designed for both comfort and entertaining, the home features soaring ceilings that create the presence of a two-story residence and a welcoming family room with fireplace. Outdoor living is equally impressive with a resort-style pool and spa, outdoor kitchen with built-in grill and bar, and expansive entertaining areas overlooking the lush oversized lot. Residents of Bay Colony Shores enjoy an unparalleled amenity package including a private clubhouse offering both formal and casual dining, a state-of-the-art fitness center, and tennis and pickleball facilities. Ownership also includes exclusive access to the renowned Bay Colony Beach Club, where residents enjoy attended beach service, elegant beachfront dining, and sunset cocktails along the Gulf of Mexico. Optional membership opportunities are available at the Bay Colony Golf Club as well as Pelican Bay’s world-class golf offerings. Perfectly positioned just minutes from Waterside Shops, Artis—Naples, Mercato, and the fine dining and boutiques of 5th Avenue South, this exceptional property represents the very best of the Naples luxury lifestyle.

328 SEDGWICK CT, Naples

7310 Tilden LN, Naples
$5,775,000
6 Beds ⋅ 9.5 Baths ⋅ 224012719 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status ⋅ 22,651 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 0.52 Acres
PRICE REDUCED Lowest price per sq/ft home in Pelican Bay. Welcome to the epitome of luxury living in prestigious Bay Colony Shores! Nestled within the exclusive enclave, this magnificent estate presents an unparalleled fusion of opulence and architectural brilliance, boasting over 10,000 square feet of meticulously crafted living space. Step inside this grand residence to discover 6 palatial bedrooms, each accompanied by its own full en-suite bathroom, ensuring absolute comfort and privacy for residents and guests alike. In addition to these lavish accommodations, the estate boasts two additional half baths, perfectly catering to the needs of modern living and entertaining. Indulge in the height of relaxation and sophistication with a master suite that exudes luxury, complete with a private lounge and his and her study areas for added convenience. Entertain in style within the confines of a billiard room and theatre room, providing an unrivaled entertainment experience for all. Outside, a sprawling outdoor oasis awaits, featuring an oversized pool and spa for refreshing dips and sun-drenched lounging, enveloped by meticulously manicured landscapes. Additionally, a private plunge pool off the master bedroom offers an exclusive retreat, while a soaking outdoor hot tub adjacent to the master bath provides the ultimate in relaxation and rejuvenation. Throughout the estate, architectural details abound, showcasing impeccable craftsmanship and timeless elegance at every turn. Full house generator installed in 2023, roof 2012, no flooding during any of the storms.

7310 Tilden LN, Naples

7261 Tilden LN, Naples
$6,200,000
5 Beds ⋅ 7.5 Baths ⋅ 225074943 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status ⋅ 20,909 Sqft. Lot ⋅ 0.48 Acres
Naples’ ultimate community in beachfront luxury, privacy and exclusivity rests behind the impressive, manned gates of Bay Colony! This home of Timeless Beauty, stands tall on a COVETED LOT, and overlooks the Estuary waters in Bay Colony Shores! It combines sophisticated elegance with practical living, and can adapt to any design aesthetic. Drawn by Stofft Cooney Architects as a unique ONE FLOOR home, it serves as an intimate space for two or expands to welcome both overnight guests or large gatherings for entertaining. The sundrenched Living Room is centered around a rare Keystone Fireplace and two-story windows that showcase the estuary scenes. A soft-toned charming Kitchen features Taj Mahal Quartzite and is open to the Family Room and Breakfast Room where two glass walls of disappearing corner sliders unite Interiors with the Outdoor Activities and spectacular views of nature! The Lanai, under a towering roof high screen epitomizes an outdoor garden room under the stars! An elevated deck offers dining and seating with 3 hidden heaters for cool nights around the sofas and TV. The lower deck features a heart-warming fountain beside a large swimmable renovated pool and a charming outdoor kitchen gazebo with pool bath. Slip away to the Ultimate English Library highlighting a gas fireplace, bar and magnificent bookshelves. The generous Primary Bedroom wing demands attention with a seating area to close out the night, 2 custom closets, 2 full bathrooms and a private lanai with lounge chairs! 4 additional bedrooms, all en suite, are separated for privacy with a large Guest Media/Bunk/Hobby room used for separate guest gatherings. Of course there is a convenient Laundry with second refrigerator and an 8 x 12 air conditioned Storage Room. New Roof in 2019 and New AC System Installed. Elevations are in the 2024 coveted X500 Flood Zone! Bay Colony is the crown jewel of Naples offering a private Beach Club with Concierge Beach and Pool Service, Indoor Casual and Fine Dining, a top of the line Tennis Club on site plus all of Pelican Bay’s spectacular amenities including Pickleball, Workout and Community Center! Close by is Naples' most sophisticated shopping at Waterside Shops, the best of live music and theater at Artis Naples, and the very vibrant town center at Mercato! The VIDEO LINK above is a must see to understand the wonderful flow of this floor plan!

7261 Tilden LN, Naples

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!